Shelter Island
New York
Shelter Island Gas Prices - Find the Lowest Gas Prices in Shelter Island, NY
Search for the lowest gasoline prices in Shelter Island, NY. Find local Shelter Island gas prices and Shelter Island gas stations with the best prices to fill up at the pump today
National and New York Gas Price Averages
| National Avg. | NY Reg. Avg. | NY Plus Avg. | NY Prem. Avg. | NY Diesel Avg. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
$3.160
12/03/2025
|
$3.165
12/03/2025
|
$3.681
12/03/2025
|
$4.060
12/03/2025
|
$3.912
12/03/2025
|
Today's lowest gas prices in New York and around Shelter Island
| Station | Regular | Plus | Premium | Diesel |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Mike's Trading Post 2342 Printup Rd, Sanborn, NY |
$2.59
12/03/2025
|
12/03/2025
|
$3.88
12/03/2025
|
$3.25
12/03/2025
|
Ron's Smoke Shop 5001 NY-417, Allegany, NY |
$2.61
12/03/2025
|
$2.91
12/03/2025
|
12/03/2025
|
12/03/2025
|
Add an Event
See All Events
Local Events
Preservation Hall Jazz Band: A Creole Christmas
Friday, Dec 5, 2025 at 8:00pm
Riverhead, NY
More info »
Christmas Concert - Sir John Rutter's Christmas
Friday, Dec 12, 2025 at 7:00pm
Deep River, CT
More info »
Christmas Concert - Sir John Rutter's Christmas
Sunday, Dec 14, 2025 at 3:00am
Deep River, CT
More info »
See All Events
In and Around Shelter Island, NY